Brown University School of Public Health │ Continuum

Continuum

Magazine of the Brown University School of Public Health

  • Home
  • Students
  • Faculty
  • Alumni
  • Research
  • Events
  • Community
  • Current Issue
  • Past Issues
    • Spring 2020
    • Fall 2019
    • Spring 2019
    • Winter 2018
    • Fall 2018
    • Spring 2017
    • Spring 2016
    • Fall 2016
    • Spring 2015
Current Issue, Fall 2020, In the News, Research, Uncategorized

Stay-at-home orders significantly associated with reduced spread of COVID-19, study finds

By Kerry Benson · Posted: December 15, 2020

As COVID-19 swept across the nation, most states went into lockdown—new research and state-by-state data suggests that stay-at-home orders helped slow the pandemic significantly.

ACROSS THE GLOBE, COVID-19 has infected more than 33 million people to date and has killed more than one million—and the United States has been hit especially hard. Although the U.S. comprises just 4.2% of the global population, it accounted for approximately 33% of all reported infections by the end of April.

However, most U.S. states eventually imposed stay-at-home orders, and those orders appear to have significantly slowed the spread of the disease for the nation as a whole.

These findings—along with a state-by- state breakdown of how quickly COVID-19 spread before and after lockdown orders—were published in the Journal of Infectious Diseases on August 1.

“Understanding the trajectory of the epidemic in the U.S. is critical, and measuring the impact of stay-at-home orders on epidemic growth offers evidence for current and future COVID-19 control and containment measures,” said Mark Lurie, an associate professor of epidemiology. “While this was not a randomized trial, and therefore we cannot establish causation, what was clear in our study is that stay-at-home orders were significantly associated with slowing epidemic growth rates.”

Lurie was the lead co-author for the study as part of a team of researchers from Brown’s School of Public Health and Warren Alpert School of Medicine.

The study calculated the pandemic doubling time—the amount of time it takes for the number of cases to double—on both a national level and for individual states. An increase in doubling time indicates a slowing pandemic.

“We hope that these findings contribute to a growing body of evidence aimed at studying the full course of COVID-19 in America.”

— Joe Silva, doctoral student in health services research

Before the effects of widespread lockdowns became apparent—from March 4 until April 4—the national pandemic doubling time was 2.68 days. This doubling time increased significantly, to an average of 15 days, in the period between April 5 and April 30. In other words, the number of cases doubled in less than three days before mitigation measures were put into place. In contrast, after mitigation measures, the number of cases took more than two weeks to double.

But while doubling time increased in all states, the rate of increase varied. On average, the 45 states with stay-at-home orders in place added about 12.27 days to their doubling time, indicating significant slowing of disease spread. Meanwhile, the five states without stay-at-home orders—Arkansas, Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota, and South Dakota—added only about six days to their doubling time, and four of these states exhibited some of the worst doubling rates in the nation.

“We hope that these findings contribute to a growing body of evidence aimed at studying the full course of COVID-19 in America,” said Joe Silva, a Ph.D. student in the School of Public Health and lead co-author on the study. “This study does not imply stay-at-home orders were the sole factor that drove the observed increase in epidemic doubling time, but the data may be representative of the impact of multiple public health measures.”

As the researchers published their findings, they did so aware that the U.S. is far from having successfully addressed the COVID-19 pandemic, he added.

“Our study period included data through the end of April, and since then cases have increased beyond what was previously thought to be the peak of the pandemic within our borders,” Silva said. “During this time, states have also removed stay-at-home orders, and it will be just as important to study the potential impacts on disease spread after these measures were no longer in place.”

In addition to Lurie and Silva, other authors on the study were Rachel Yorlets, Jun Tao, and Philip Chan.

Share Tweet

Kerry Benson

You Might Also Like

  • Covid Mask Current Issue

    Lessons Learned

  • Current Issue

    Letter from the Dean

  • Jha walking with students Current Issue

    In Profile: Taking the Helm During a Pandemic

Recent Research News:All Research News

  • Current Issue

    Stay-at-home orders significantly associated with reduced spread of COVID-19, study finds

    New research and data suggests that stay-at-home orders helped slow the pandemic significantly. ...

    On December 15, 2020 / By Kerry Benson
  • Current Issue

    To examine the effects of COVID-19 on communities, Brown researchers turn to data

    Brown University projects examine effects on nursing homes and medical care ...

    On December 15, 2020 / By Emilijia Sagaityte
  • Current Issue

    The Pandemic’s Emotional Toll

    A study led by doctoral student Catherine Ettman finds COVID-19 has led to a nearly a three-fold increase in depression. ...

    On December 15, 2020 / By Brown Public Health
  • Mindfulness pose
    Research

    It really is in your head— but how does it work?

    The Mindfulness Center at Brown University is working to explain why mindfulness makes us healthier. ...

    On April 24, 2020 / By Sarah C. Baldwin '87, MFA
  • award
    Faculty

    Faculty Honors

    Public Health faculty were honored by Brown’s Office of the Vice President for Research ...

    On April 23, 2020 / By Brown Public Health
  • Elderly person practices mindfulness
    In the News

    Mindfulness Training May Help Lower Blood Pressure

    A study led by Professor Eric Loucks, Ph.D., finds that mindfulness could reduce blood pressure by enhancing attention control, emotion regulation and self-awareness of both healthy and unhealthy ...

    On April 23, 2020 / By Kerry Benson
  • Dr. Shireman and Dr. Besdine
    Fall 2019

    Aging Gracefully: The Center for Gerontology and Healthcare Research

    30 years of accomplishment by Brown’s Center for Gerontology and Healthcare Research ...

    On November 2, 2019 / By Laura Kallio Joyce, P'22

About

Continuum is the official publication of the Brown University School of Public Health. It focuses on the activities of our students, faculty and alumni. Please enjoy our digital edition of the magazine.

Contact

If you have any suggestions for Continuum, contact us at public_health@brown.edu.

Connect

Follow us on Twitter and Facebook, and visit the School of Public Health, for more information.

Give

Please use the online giving form to support this magazine and its mission.

© 2016-2021 Brown University School of Public Health. All rights reserved.